Why I Like the Book Better Than the Movie
Of course I don’t always like the book better than the movie. “The Third Man,” for instance is much better as a movie. “Casablanca” is my favorite movie. It never was a book, but if it was, I would still think the movie was better. Nevertheless, in nearly all cases the book is far better, for me anyway, because it comes with Instant Replay.
You know what I mean by Instant Replay. It is what saves the day for you when you are watching a football game and somehow you watch the running back go off tackle when actually the quarterback bootlegged the ball. Instant Replay is what allows you to see what happened, whether on the TV at home or on the Jumbotron at the stadium.
When you’re watching a movie, though, either on the TV or at the theaer, there is nio Instant Replay. It is up to you to Pay Attention, as Patricia continually reminds me. Be prepared. Go to the bathroom before the movie begins. Then, during the show, listen carefully to each line, and scrutinize each scene, for details, like “Rosebud,” which yes, I managed to miss. I’m sorry, but
somehow I have been gifted with the talent to Misinterpret, whether a road sign or a lyric. Even if I scrutinize the scene and attend the lines, I have a God-given ability not to see what the artist was driving at. (In a weak self-defense I can say that is also a trait that means being fair, being able to see more than one side of the question. The lady left town to get married. Two years later, she came back for a visit without her husband. Did that mean she had divorced? That is what was meant, Particia says. I say maybe her husband was busy and just couldn't make the trip.)
Anyway, whatever the reason, whenever I begin to watch a movie I know in my heart I’m going to miss something somewhere. That is why the book is better. When you realize you can’t figure out what’s going on, you just go back, find the critical passage, and read it again. it is Instant Replay. This, in a nutshell, is why for me the book is always better than the movie.